Episode Transcript
The Finance Ghost: Welcome to episode 300 of Magic Markets. What a nice thing to be able to say out loud. That is a wonderful milestone for us. Thank you to those of you who have been on this journey with us throughout, because I know there are a few of you out there, for sure, who have been here since episode one. So, thank you.
This week, we will be looking at the automotive sector. Not just because we like cars (which we both do), but also because there's big stuff happening in the space, including some news from Mercedes-Benz that Moe will cover.
On my side, I'll be talking about the South African picture and the recent update from Metair that showed just how many challenges our industrial companies really need to deal with – including, but not exclusively, in that value chain.
Before we get to that, I just want to reference a piece I saw in the Financial Mail last week. Bobby Ramagwede, the CEO of the Automobile Association (AA) of South Africa, told the Financial Mail that, and I quote here: "It's time for the OEM leaders to speak truth to power."
Strong words here about the impact of Chinese imports on the sector. And here, obviously, he's talking about the brands that manufacture in South Africa, in the Eastern Cape, etcetera.
That same article has a stat that says that South Africa is dependent on the sector for a shockingly high 5% of GDP. Now, assuming that stat is accurate (which it probably is), that's a lot. This clearly matters.
But before we get to the South African story, Moe, you are, as always, going to give us some global context to this. And I thank you for having done 300 of these with me. That's a pretty decent innings, my friend.
Mohammed Nalla: Indeed, Ghost. 300. That's a lovely milestone. I guess it's quite fitting we're doing a topic that we both love. We both love cars. And in Magic Markets Premium, we're covering BMW this week, so sticking with that theme. I know I like BMWs. I think you do too.
But, Ghost, let's get back on topic here. The automotive sector is always interesting in that you get to see many macro themes all play out at once.
At the moment, you've got trade wars; you've got tariffs; you've also got industrial policy and governments really trying to protect manufacturing jobs. And then, on top of that, when you look at the consumer, you've got high interest rates, which are affecting vehicle affordability.
And then, on top of that, you've got the energy transition and China completely disrupting the traditional economics of the industry. So, that's a lot going on.
Let's try to unpack some of these elements. The old automotive model was fairly straightforward. You had an OEM that developed a vehicle platform. It then put it into a handful of large factories and exported those vehicles into multiple markets. Now, that's an oversimplification, but it is the old model.
If we look at the new model, though, it's become a lot more fragmented because this is where we see governments increasingly wanting vehicles built locally. There are social pressures. We then have the tariffs, which are changing where companies can export profitably.
China – their manufacturers are putting increasing pressure on pricing, but they're also moving so fast on batteries, software and new models. Coupled with all of this, we have the traditional manufacturers who need to invest in their existing businesses – the internal combustion engines.
Then there's hybrids, fully electric vehicles, at the same time, mainly because consumers haven't transitioned as quickly or as consistently as initially expected.
So, that confluence of a series of very large macro factors means that these companies need to consider a series of strategies all at play, all at once. And this requires a lot of focus and enormous capital, but without any certainty over which technology or which market will deliver the necessary returns.
Now, against this backdrop, let's bring it back to the SA macro picture. Here in South Africa, it was quite interesting. We've seen stronger car sales in Q3, but not stronger local manufacturing. And I know we're going to unpack this, but SA vehicle sales rose nearly 12% in Q3, but domestic production was down 9%. And exports – that's the big story – declined by almost 14%.
So, if we then look on a slightly more granular level, sales of imported light vehicles rose 17%, but sales of locally manufactured vehicles increased only 1.5%. So, in aggregate, South Africa is buying more cars, but an increasing share of that demand is actually benefiting factories somewhere else.
Now, the auto sector in South Africa, as you mentioned in the intro, is a large one. It employs many people. And so the risk is more than just whether a certain factory closes down. It's the longer-term picture of South Africa needing to compete with countries like Thailand, China, India, Mexico and even Eastern Europe. And they're competing for existing platforms as well as the next vehicle platform.
The elements that a manufacturer needs to look at range from issues like labour and production costs (those feature quite prominently in South Africa) to then also access to export markets, electricity, logistics, government incentives, and the strength of the local supplier base.
And these are issues not just facing South African auto operations, but also countries where we've seen the giants of global auto manufacturing, like Germany.
The Finance Ghost: Yeah, exactly, Moe. That's the point. It's tough for these South African OEMs, but they are ultimately just the international manufacturing branches of companies that are headquartered elsewhere, including the likes of Mercedes-Benz trying to still manufacture cars in places like Germany.
There was some terrible news out of Volkswagen earlier this year about their plans in Germany. Now it seems like Mercedes-Benz has also halted further investment on that side.
It's not sounding very good.
Perhaps you can just take us through whether it's really hardball in a labour negotiation? Are they just waiting for someone to call their bluff, potentially, here? Or do you think that Germany is just no longer a competitive place to manufacture?
Mohammed Nalla: Yeah, Ghost, I think there's an element of hardball here. Remember, in Germany, the labour unions are still quite powerful. They have representation on a lot of these companies' boards, and so Mercedes is negotiating with the works council and unions over labour costs.
I wouldn't interpret this as a final decision to permanently abandon Germany. Halting investment and raising the prospect of plant closures does increase the pressure in those negotiations. The fact that Mercedes can credibly make a threat like this is quite telling.
And management says labour costs at its German plants can be up to (wait for it) five times higher than at plants in Eastern Europe, fairly close to Germany.
At the same time, Mercedes is needing to deal with weaker demand in China. They've got stronger Chinese competition – not just in China, but in Europe as well. They've got tariffs in the US and this enormous cost of the transition towards electric vehicles.
Now, for decades, the German industrial bargain was that German higher wages could be supported by superior engineering, high productivity and a very strong export franchise. And that held for a very long time.
But the problem is that, more recently, Chinese manufacturers have really closed part of the quality gap, and they've maintained their cost advantage. So, China is not really competing only at the cheap end of the market. We've seen some fantastic vehicles come out of there.
This isn't necessarily the end of German car manufacturing, but it does mean that that industrial heritage is no longer enough to guarantee investment and German success.
Now, again, bringing it back to South Africa. South Africa shouldn't assume that investment leaving Germany will automatically come to South Africa. Let's look at Mercedes in South Africa specifically.
We've got that East London plant. It produces the C-Class. The US was historically an important export market for vehicles produced there. But South African vehicle exports to the US fell by more than 80% between 2024 and 2025 after the introduction of a 25% auto tariff.
Now, Mercedes-Benz South Africa was particularly exposed to that disruption. And so, bringing the German and SA stories together, I think the pressure in Germany is mainly about costs. The pressure in South Africa is more logistics uncertainty. You've got policy uncertainty and access to other export markets.
And for a global firm struggling to maintain its place as an auto powerhouse, the question’s actually quite simple, even if the answer isn't. The question is: where can Mercedes, or any global auto firm, manufacture a vehicle competitively and then reliably get it to the customer?
Now, I don't want to end on a doom-and-gloom story as we close this part of the discussion off. It's not all doom and gloom. There's another positive counterexample, and that is BMW's Rosslyn plant. It received a R4.2 billion investment for the latest X3, and it's the only BMW facility globally producing an X3 plug-in hybrid.
This shows that South Africa can still win some very important global mandates, but those mandates must be continually earned, and it's getting really tough globally.
The Finance Ghost: Yeah, Moe. That's fantastic. And that new X3 does look rather cool, I've got to say. In a sea of sameness of Chinese SUVs, that new X3 is pretty rad. So, nice to know that that's getting some love here in South Africa.
Mohammed Nalla: That's why we're both BMW fans. I must say that some of the newer designs I've seen (like the new 3 Series), I'm not that much of a fan.
I want to bring the discussion back to South Africa. You alluded to some very worrying stats earlier. Some strong words from a very high-powered person in the automotive sector. What's happening down there?
The Finance Ghost: Yeah, so there's a lot to unpack here in terms of local disruption. I'm definitely not about to try to do it all.
Also, just keep in mind that there are various points in the value chain, so there would technically be enough to fill probably 10 shows, but we're not going to do that.
You've got the companies that are selling to consumers directly. So, you've got the likes of CMH, Motus.
Motus, by the way, very much a vertically integrated play. I spoke to that management team recently on another podcast, and they happen to be the importers for several brands, including Kia and Hyundai – companies that led the charge in the last round of automotive disruption. But it doesn't feel like South Korea had quite the impact that we've seen from China, certainly. Still, it did have an impact.
Then you've got the OEMs manufacturing in South Africa (which is what we've been talking about), both for the local market and for export. This is where the comments by the AA CEO were focused.
And if it sounds bad in terms of how important this is for South Africa as a whole, then it's even worse when you look at areas like the Eastern Cape, where there haven't necessarily been great alternatives emerging from an industrial perspective. There are some towns that feel like they are largely reliant on just one or two factories.
Still, if we stick with that manufacturing side, we can go up the value chain. We will then hit our noses on a locally listed company, which is Metair.
Metair may not be a household name in South Africa, but industrial players often aren't. The products, though, are sitting in many locally produced cars. Wiring harnesses, all kinds of other components, headlights, springs, plastic injection moulding – all sorts.
And the latest news at the company, unfortunately, is terrible. I wrote about it for Daily Maverick as well this week because I think it's an announcement that needs to be seen and heard. We need to get better at keeping public representatives accountable.
The Durban Gateway Terminal has been awful. It has suffered such significant operational challenges that Metair has experienced delays at the port of nearly 20 days at times.
Now, just think about this in a manufacturing environment. Remember how the Japanese talk about Just-In-Time and that kind of thing? How on earth do you operate like that with a 20-day delay out of nowhere?
So, raw materials get in, they get stuck. You can't now manufacture the components at Metair that need to go onto the production line for a Ford Ranger, for example. So, we're losing out on this local beneficiation.
Then we're losing out on profitable beneficiation because Metair has got to try to do something. You can't have a scenario where the production line stops at the OEM. So, they have to airfreight stuff in, or they have to use overtime to actually make up for it and make sure that they are fulfilling their contractual obligations.
Because their OEMs don't want to hear about it. They're not going to pay Metair back on this. There's just not a lot of money running around in this value chain. There's no fat right now. So, none of these costs can be recouped at the moment.
And to make it even worse, Metair has been weak. They've been severely struggling to get to this point (and maybe we'll talk about that just now).
But just to touch on the impact of these specific new issues, they reckon that these problems will be between 20% and 25% of EBITDA in value.
Now, if you've looked at an income statement and you understand how EBITDA filters all the way down (especially when there's lots of debt), if you're losing up to a quarter of your EBITDA, it's not pretty by the bottom of the income statement.
And a lot of investors don't seem to be hanging around to wait and see what this looks like. The share price got smashed 35% on the date of release of this update. So, just a complete indictment, Moe, on the state of industrial production in South Africa.
Mohammed Nalla: Wow. Ghost, that's shockingly bad for Metair, right? And I'm assuming this is on top of all of the existing risks we just mentioned – that they face from the Chinese, from Indian disruption, other emerging markets?
The Finance Ghost: Absolutely, it is. And I think what's particularly heartbreaking is that Metair was just starting to get some traction in its turnaround. And this is after bad luck, after bad luck, after bad luck.
We could do a whole show on Metair's luck.
They're either getting huge fines in the European Union or there was that flooding at the Toyota plant in Durban. That had a huge impact on their business. I promise you, it's like a horror movie. It's just one thing after the next.
So, if you actually go back to Metair's report for the six months to June, you'll find some interesting disclosure in there that their OEM business is 67% of group revenue. So, pretty much two-thirds, on the nose.
The customers here: Toyota, fine. Ford, probably struggling. Isuzu, Volkswagen (Volkswagen is one of the toughest stories right now), and Mahindra (which is at least Indian, so maybe there's a chance there that their sales are decent). Lots of legacy brands here. Some are really struggling.
A stat that maybe shows the problem (and you've alluded to a few of them earlier as well): in that six-month period that Metair was reporting on, South African vehicle exports were down 7.8% year on year. So, it's not just a local problem. It's the international market filtering down into our manufacturing here.
So, two-thirds of the company is exposed to a sector under pressure, and the rest is not exactly a happy story either. AutoZone, for example, has been running roughly six months behind its plans after being acquired out of business rescue. The European battery business is facing an enormous fine that is currently being appealed as well.
Overall, for the interim period, it actually says a lot that Metair was pretty happy to just have stable revenue and an EBIT decrease of just 1%.
In fact, Moe, that siren you can hear in the background right now, I'm going to leave it in because it actually feels exactly in line with how life is going right now for Metair. They need an ambulance.
HEPS from continuing operations was up by 4%, so they were actually starting to do well. You know, the ambulance was working, and now along came this issue.
And the problem is the balance sheet, especially what we've learned after the latest numbers. Now take what you just learned about a quarter of EBITDA could be gone and apply it to this. If you look in the interims, you will find that the debt has been housed in three separate ring-fenced structures. That's your first sign that things are not good.
The one structure is the South African companies, excluding Hesto, as the main business in OEM. The second one would be Hesto itself, and the third one would be Rombat, which is that European battery business that has been whacked with a fine by the regulators on that side. It's not good.
So, we honestly don't have time on this podcast to fully unpack how hard it all is, but I'll give you a couple of numbers. R3.9 billion worth of debt facilities in that SA obligor group. R1.5 billion in Hesto. So, just in South Africa alone, we're looking at almost R5.5 billion in debt across those two.
To show you how heavily indebted the company is with reference to things like EBITDA, we can look at the covenants. For that SA obligor group, total net debt to EBITDA of no more than 4.35x. When last did you see a net debt to EBITDA of above 4x, Moe? That's a high number. Within Hesto, the maximum in the covenant is 2.5x.
If you look at the underlying debt rates, the margin over ZARONIA sits at between 2% and around 4.2%. At the top end, that means they are paying rates close to what SMEs typically have to pay when they are borrowing money. And remember, this is a listed company, and this was before the latest issue.
Now, Metair has to go and have even tougher conversations with its banks, all because the Durban port infrastructure has severely let them down. This company just cannot catch a break. It's extraordinary. It is by far the unluckiest company on the JSE.
Mohammed Nalla: Ghost, I'm glad you left that siren in there. In fact, I thought you were playing fancy games with sound effects on our show here.
The Finance Ghost: No, not that fancy.
Mohammed Nalla: [laughing] It certainly sounds like an emergency. Obviously, the banks are going to have to have those very tough discussions, and I guess maybe that's also why the price of the funding is that high. It's got to reflect some of these risks in Durban port infrastructure. This is a business that relies on that.
Hopefully policymakers in South Africa are having a listen to this podcast and these discussions, because a failure at the port doesn't just impact the auto manufacturers like Metair. I've spoken to a number of business leaders across various industries. These bottlenecks are becoming a serious problem for South Africa's growth aspirations and overall competitiveness.
Ghost, to bring the show to a wrap, my key takeaway on the auto discussion we just had is that strong car sales don't necessarily mean strong local manufacturing. You've certainly seen that in the South African macro data. It's what industry leaders are telling us.
And I know it sounds obvious, but overall investment flows to countries that can combine competitive costs, reliable logistics (*whah* – bad sound effect for South Africa there), and access to export markets.
Now, South Africa can be competitive, but it can't take its foot off the gas (and you'll pardon the pun there). It really has a lot of work to do on that front just to overcome some of its geographical - it's very far from a couple of key export markets - you've got to overcome that and just get some of the building blocks right.
Now, Ghost, I know we're going to pick up on that OEM side of the story in Magic Markets Premium this week. I mentioned we're looking at BMW, so it'll be very interesting to see how that plays into the performance of a global company at scale, with some of these macro themes at play.
To our listeners, that's all we've got for you this week. Let us know what you thought of the show. Hit us up on social media.
It’s @MagicMarketsPod, @FinanceGhost and @MohammedNalla, all on X, or go find us on LinkedIn. Pop us a note on there.
Until next week – same time, same place. Thanks, and cheers.
The Finance Ghost: Ciao.